(Photo courtesy Urban Alchemy) In 2022, as cities were finding their footing after the pandemic, Stanford University sociology professor Forrest Stuart took a walk through San Francisco’s Tenderloin neighborhood. He’d seen the sensational headlines about the proliferation of drug activity, homeless encampments, and violent crime in the neighborhood. “I’m used to these things being kind of overblown until I took a trip into the Tenderloin and I saw just how underestimated and how understated things were,” he says. Everything from illicit drug use to homelessness was out in the open. But as he walked along Hyde Street, something gave him pause. One particular corner was cleaner, quieter, even inviting. He noticed a man on that corner wearing a black and green vest, watching over the block — not like a cop on patrol, but like a steward. The man, he soon found out, worked for Urban Alchemy. Founded in 2018 in San Francisco, Urban Alchemy is among a handful of nonprofits nationwide that seek to keep formerly incarcerated people from reentering the carceral system by connecting them with housing and job opportunities. Urban Alchemy directly employs the formerly incarcerated, who are mostly middle-aged or older Brown and Black men who served long-term or life sentences, and places them in interim housing while training and employing them to complete various sanitation and environmental work for cities. Now, newly published research led by Stuart shows that Urban Alchemy’s model has successfully cut total crime in the neighborhood by about 20%, and reduced crime related to behavioral health and drugs by even more. “This is one study, but the numbers are significant,” Stuarts says. (Photo courtesy Urban Alchemy) Urban Alchemy’s work in the Tenderloin The Tenderloin has a deep and intertwined history with the city’s newcomers and marginalized communities, including the LGBTQ+ protestors and Southeast Asian immigrants. It is also often on the front lines of San Francisco’s most rampant urban issues like gentrification and homelessness. The city’s investments and efforts to revitalize the neighborhood have been, at best, inconsistent decade to decade . But since the COVID-19 pandemic, the Tenderloin has seemingly become the embodiment of every crisis the city has yet to solve. Affordability and lack of housing became highly visible and undeniable as encampments of houseless people — which were already scattered through the neigbhorhood—grew rapidly . Rates of crime also rose during that period in several categories, including larceny, homicides, and drug activity. In 2022 alone, two-thirds of the city’s reported criminal drug activity came from the Tenderloin , according to city data. Urban Alchemy and the city began working together in 2019, and the nonprofit began deploying their employees to encampments in the Tenderloin. Urban Alchemy’s first major contract with San Francisco involved its practitioners — as the nonprofit calls its employees — cleaning several public restrooms around the city. After a few months, the nonprofit and the city noticed that not only did bathrooms remain clean, but the surrounding areas felt safer. “It was just a way to provide employment for folks who couldn’t work anywhere else,” says Lena Miller, founder of the nonprofit .” And then, certain government officials started noticing that crime dropped [around the restrooms].” Miller, who holds a doctorate in psychology from the University of San Francisco and who has worked for decades with low-income populations, eventually began incorporating modules on public safety through trauma-informed practices into their practitioner training. (Photo courtesy Urban Alchemy) Urban Alchemy’s current model Today, new Urban Alchemy employees go through a 40-hour training week. This includes learning psychological strategies like de-escalation and relationship-building, as well as life-saving skills like CPR and administering Narcan. They are then deployed for a 90-day probationary period, with at least a month under supervision, at a designated street corner. At these corners, practitioners are expected to keep the area clean and interact with the public. The public safety impact mostly comes from those interactions. Miller explains that some days the interactions are as meaningful and life-altering as connecting folks to safe consumption sites or people to housing resources. Other days, it could be as simple as buying someone a coffee, handing out sanitary items, or escorting local children to school. “Every interaction, no matter how small, goes a long way,” she says. Peer-reviewed research by Stuart and his colleagues, published in the open-source scientific journal PNAS Nexus , found that in areas where Urban Alchemy operated, there was an associated 20% drop in total reported crime, including a 27% reduction in behavioral health-related crime, a 29% reduction in drug-related crime, and no increase in violent crime. They detail these outcomes in their recently published study on Urban Alchemy, “Civilianized Safety Practitioners Reduce Crime and Disorder.” According to the nonprofit’s own data, Urban Alchemy reports a less-than-2% recidivism rate for their employees. National data generally estimates a more than 50% recidivism rate; the Brennan Center for Justice , which calculates its rates from the Bureau of Justice Statistics, reports that 62% of previously incarcerated people will be rearrested within three years of release and 39% will return to prison. Urban Alchemy now operates in eight other cities: Los Angeles, Oakland, Culver City, California; Portland, Oregon; Birmingham, Alabama; Santa Fe, New Mexico; Denver, Colorado; and Atlanta, Georgia. For Urban Alchemy’s public safety model to work, Miller explains, a city needs to be committed to several elements. Like all nonprofit work, continued funding is crucial — it’s a wait and see process, she says. A city also has to acknowledge that this is a program based on prevention and not related to solving and reacting to crime like a local police force. But the biggest component is the workers. If a city doesn’t have access to a major prison system, there won’t be enough people qualified to do the work at the crux of the public safety aspect. California has the biggest prison system in the country, enabling Urban Alchemy to work with four cities in the state. The on-the-ground work, Miller believes, has to be done by people who have stayed long enough and have been changed by the carceral system. “People who’ve been in prison for a while have developed skills that are off the chart for knowing how to maneuver through potentially sticky situations, to read body language, to know how to relate, to show compassion, and understanding,” she says. This is starkly different to the police training that she’s familiar with, which focuses on reaction and reaction timing. She also adds that similar programs, in her experience — like cities deploying social workers directly to the streets — may not have the same outcomes because they require repeated exposure with the same people, which then builds trust. It cannot be replicated with social workers showing up during particular days or potentially traumatic events, like periodic encampment sweeps or census counts. “A lot of it is just deterrence. If you know somebody is watching the street and is taking responsibility for the street, you’re not gonna do all that. It allows the police to focus on police work, and it allows us to take the social burden,” Miller says. Urban Alchemy’s program is designed to be mutually beneficial to both cities and practitioners. The nature of their work has instilled a sense of responsibility and pride for practitioners. Both Miller and Stuart point out that many of their practitioners have found religion during their time in prison and that many of their sentences were related to gang-related activity decades ago. While the nature of crime in urban areas has changed from highly-organized gang activity to more isolated individualized criminal activity , their experience with protecting boundaries and the people within those spaces, when channeled away from the “underground economy,” and into a highly visible and very public role, becomes invaluable to their neighbors and dignifying for them. It’s a conclusion that Stuart outlines in a forthcoming study titled “Making Safety, Making Good: Credible Messengers and the Identity Work of Prisoner Reentry.” “Giving formerly incarcerated people decent wages, dignity, a new pro-social role in society where they are respected, where they become ingrained in a community where every day they’re being told they’re doing a wonderful job — that allows them to reunite with family members, and it allows them to right feel as though they’re balancing the cosmic scales,” Stuart says. Marielle Argueza was formerly Next City’s Equitable Cities Reporting Fellow for Racial Justice Narratives (in partnership with Triad City Beat in Greensboro, North Carolina) and Next City's INN/Columbia Journalism School intern. She has more than a decade of experience reporting on education, immigration, labor, criminal justice, climate and more. Her work in K-12 education is award-winning and she was recognized multiple times by the California News Publishers Association. She is a recent graduate of Columbia Journalism School, where she was Toni Stabile Investigative Fellow. Her work includes a story on Harlem’s last assisted-living facility for people living with HIV/AIDS; a profile on New York State’s first Farmers Union; and a database of deaths within the Milwaukee County Jail. She is also a recipient of other fellowships and scholarships from several notable organizations including the Asian American Journalists Association, Association of Alternative Newsmedia, ProPublica, and the Journalism and Women Symposium.
https://nextcity.org/urbanist-news/what-happens-when-formerly-incarcerated-people-look-after-a-stre