(Illustration by Pablo Merchán Montes / Unsplash) America has a massive housing shortage, estimated at 4.7 million homes. Or is it 1.5 million ? Our homelessness crisis has ballooned, with 770,000 Americans unhoused in 2024. Or was the true number closer to 1.5 million ? First-time homebuyers have shrunk to just one third of purchasers. Or have they grown to nearly half of buyers, an all-time high? Housing accounts for 16% of U.S. gross domestic product, and it is the foundation for nearly every aspect of health, stability, and well-being. Affordability dominated the midterms and will shape the 2028 race. Yet nobody fully knows what is actually happening in America’s housing markets, because our data on housing, from construction starts to eviction filings, is fragmented, shoddy, or simply nonexistent. If policymakers lack a clear, shared understanding of how the housing market is functioning—and where it is failing—how can they make informed decisions about how to fix it? That’s why, when the National Housing Crisis Task Force , co-chaired by Utah Gov. Spencer Cox and Cleveland Mayor Justin Bibb, released a series of white papers on fixing America’s housing system on Nov. 9, the first proposal was to create a National Housing Data Authority (NHDA). As authors of the white paper on data, New America proposes that this body would build and maintain the country’s housing data infrastructure, and help state and local leaders use that data to tackle our biggest supply, stability, affordability and quality challenges. Creating an NHDA would follow a well-established precedent. Between 1862 and 1992, the United States created 13 principal statistical agencies to track information for the sectors that most impact our economy and daily life – including the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the National Center for Education Statistics and the Bureau of Justice Statistics. The creation of these agencies reflects a national judgment that the sectors behind them are too important to manage without trusted, sustained data. And yet housing, which is the bedrock of household and community well-being, has no equivalent. The problem isn’t that America collects no housing data. The U.S. actually collects a substantial amount of housing data, much of it high-quality and nationally representative, particularly through the U.S. Census Bureau. The problem is that our housing data mirrors our housing system: it’s decentralized and divided among thousands of actors, providing a patchwork of partial views of housing, but never a complete picture. That’s because housing decisions are divided across all levels of government and private actors. Local governments shape where and how housing can be built through land-use rules and permitting; states design and administer housing programs and establish regulatory frameworks; and federal agencies influence housing production and preservation through financing, subsidies, and regulation. The result is thousands of geographically distinct housing markets, with data stored in hundreds of places, using different definitions and time periods. No single entity, public or private, is responsible for making sense of it. This data fragmentation has real consequences. Families who live in cars or doubled up with relatives often don’t appear in official counts, and can’t access homelessness benefits as a result. Because property ownership is rarely tracked, cities struggle to hold negligent landlords accountable. And because policymakers don’t have good data to monitor the performance of housing programs, they don’t know what is actually impacting affordability. This particular data gap will have a major impact on the implementation of the recently-enacted federal housing legislation, the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act. The ROAD Act encourages construction, cuts red tape, and eases rules for manufactured housing, but we don’t have the data infrastructure to track where it has the most impact and why. If we want to improve housing stability, availability, quality, and affordability, then we must have the data to track these major indicators. That’s why we’re proposing a National Housing Data Authority, a federal or quasi-federal body charged with building and maintaining America’s housing data infrastructure. It wouldn’t replace data that agencies, states and cities already collect, or pour everything into one giant database. Instead, it would provide the connective tissue that makes existing data usable, the sustained resources and capacity to fill the gaps in quality and coverage of our current housing data system. An NHDA would have three core functions. A National Housing Data Exchange would serve as a single point of access to the public and private housing data that already exists. It would negotiate access to costly proprietary datasets, link records across sources, and set common benchmarks, such as how many homes each city needs to build or preserve. A Housing Data Action Lab would identify the most urgent data gaps, bring together practitioners, researchers, and affected communities to set priorities and turn findings into concrete action plans. It would also have the funding, capacity, and technology to turn data gaps into data that is useful for governance and action. A State and Local Housing Data Hub would give cities, counties, and states the funding, technical help, and shared standards they need to modernize their data infrastructure. Building this local capacity ensures that cities and counties can actually leverage newly available data. These data gaps are especially stark in the rental market. Nearly half of all renter households (22.7 million) spend more than 30% of their income on rent and utilities, yet timely, address-level data on rents, ownership, and housing conditions remain largely inaccessible. Much of what does exist is proprietary, leaving our understanding of an entire market dependent on opaque private systems. A first step should be a one-year initiative to map existing rental data, identify critical gaps, and develop a roadmap for improving its availability and quality. By bringing together public agencies, private data holders, researchers, and philanthropy, this effort could lay the groundwork for a more transparent rental data infrastructure and help define the role of a proposed National Housing Data Authority. We estimate the National Housing Data Authority would need $75 million to $100 million in its first year, in line with other federal statistical agencies, and importantly, it cannot be a one-time investment or short-term pilot. For too long, housing actors have been making housing decisions based on what is measured rather than what matters most. At a time when housing costs and quality are straining households across the country, we can no longer afford to treat housing data as anything but critical. Yuliya Panfil is Senior Fellow and Director at the Future of Land and Housing program at New America. Sabiha Zainulbhai is the Deputy Director of Strategy and Policy at the Future of Land and Housing program at New America.
https://nextcity.org/urbanist-news/the-case-for-a-national-housing-data-authority